Alex christens a new type of episodes called ‘Walking Therapy’, despite the fact that several episodes of the kind have already been published. In this episode he discusses the wide range of styles and approaches to drawing he observed in a workshop for kids, and ponders why this early diversity doesn’t seem to carry through to the commercial art world.
Transcript
Nobody gave me sin for this
That’s reason why I try both
If all is old, I can see a thousand times of this
If all is old, I can see a thousand times of this
If all is old, I can see a thousand times of this
If all is old, I can see a thousand times of this
If all is old, I can see a thousand times of this
If all is old, I can see a thousand times of this
If all is old, I can see a thousand times of this
If all is old, I can see a thousand times of this
If all is old, I can see a thousand times of this
If all is old, I can see a thousand times of this
If all is old, I can see a thousand times of this
If all is old, I can see a thousand times of this
If all is old, I can see a thousand times of this
like this. To be clear even if you just for example looked at the landscapes of the people
in this group or one of the local galleries you would see quite a variance of style even there
not just dictated by medium but just totally different stylistic and subject matter approaches
to the same scenery and geography and I think within that you get more of a more of a sense
of what’s going on but it was really brought to my attention a few weeks ago when a group of us
ran an arts day for a local school these were 14 year old kids from the local secondary school
we set up the local town hall and set up with various stations and it was a bit like large
group speed dating for artistic techniques so start off doing some printing and then move around
to do miniature painting and then making little zines and so there was quite a diversity there
just in terms of the approaches that we were advocating and helping these these kids make
stuff in. I was responsible for a sort of a timeout station where anyone who wasn’t really
getting on with or had finished early on the one of the main stations could come and sit with me
what I was helping them do was draw with pencil graphite pencil so nothing particularly outlandish
or radical thanks to years and years of what I now recognize as using the activity of drawing
with pencils as a way to regulate and calm and recent myself I’m quite good with graphite pencils
some would say very good and because it was a sort of regulation exercise with me it involved
doing very sort of detailed hyper real depictions of bits of pieces of photos or image imagery I had
so I can I can draw a still life or a portrait it’ll be pretty good most of the time. Anyway
I’ve done a couple of these sessions now where the idea is partially about getting people used to or
getting them to think slightly differently about pencil as a medium both in terms of the materials
themselves but also in terms of using pencil as a way to explore the facets of of the world around
us in terms of things within their surroundings light and shade shape and form and so on and
pencil is quite good for this because it’s very versatile and ultimately exists to depict shading
light and shade and you don’t have to be distracted unless you happen to be doing color pencils
by things like the color although you do have to take it into account ultimately your job is to
transfer this thing in front of me into something that’s two-dimensional and grayscale that looks
three-dimensional and it’s not an easy medium to work with per se but it is an easy medium to get
started and to get some level of results with quite quickly and it’s certainly one of the easier
mediums to help people understand shape form light and shade with so I have a sort of a bit of a
routine of materials that introduce people to this concept that essentially moves them from drawing
spheres of little wooden balls and cubes have little cubes in place with a sort of a fairly
a bleak light source that helps it cast the shadow and get them thinking about first the
fact that there’s no lines here where do you see the lines many people’s early approach to drawing
is to draw the outline of everything they see which is not per se bad but you put yourself
in a position there where you’re only really thinking about shape rather than form and it
can be hard to sort of throw back from so I get people to observe the fact that where they see
lines particularly in a cube or the perimeter of a ball what they’re actually seeing is a boundary
between light and dark and by controlling the lighting around these very ultimately very simple
objects you can demonstrate how that changes depending on those lighting conditions and
and start drawing people’s attention to the fact that that ball doesn’t exist in
floating in space it’s actually sitting on a surface and it’s casting a shadow on that
surface but that surface is also reflecting light back at it and that a lot of people
observe that spheres are darker on one side and lighter on the other but when they’re first
starting out frequently fail to notice that the effect that the ground is having on the sphere
itself and any experienced artists working in any level of realism will recognize this
and and really the point here is not to learn how to draw a sphere it’s to get you thinking about
form shape light and shade and ultimately if you’ve got a sphere you’ve got an orange or a
melon or an apple or a human head or a planet or whatever and if you’ve got a cube you’ve got a house
or you’ve got a fridge or the beginnings of a car and these building blocks can go quite a
long way and understanding them at their rudiments might seem a little bit over the academic but once
you clear all of the clutter away from these surfaces and recognize them and their facets
then putting the clutter back all the features and the differences in shapes and the imperfections
and so on becomes a lot easier because you think about those actions in the same context as the
form itself and I’m digressing here but digressing is what I do anyway back to the kids these kids
some of which were clearly okay with following the rules and didn’t want to uh mess around
or skive off or whatever some of them did but I’m not their teacher I wasn’t there to discipline
and the ones that turned up and seemed interested in engaging I never didn’t really have time given
the the speed that they were being moved around the the main stations I didn’t really have a lot
of time to go through the whole thing so I had some sort of teaching aids in form of diagrams
and drawings that I’d done myself and tried my best ultimately had to just sort of point in
directions some paper and some pencils and say draw that and uh and maybe intervene if I needed to
what um what fascinated me was just the absolute radical difference between all the different
approaches and styles that I saw from these kids who perhaps had been influenced to a degree by
observing other artists or being taught but certainly weren’t old enough to have been
thoroughly indoctrinated in any way by any particular style or movement or approach and
you know felt quite raw the different styles and because they’re all drawing something
that’s very uniform like that they I try to light the balls in all in pretty much the same way and
they’re all exactly the same pretty much and and so although I wouldn’t exactly start calling this a
controlled scientific experiment just in terms of observing different approaches it’s not a bad way
to go because everyone’s drawing something that is very homogeneous and there’s not a lot of room
for interpretation and so I kind of was bowled over by just how radically different these kids
approaches to this was some of them were slow and methodical my my general pointers in terms of
this is don’t try and do one bit thoroughly and then move on to the next bit because it’s really
hard to keep things harmonized when you do that and also you’re making it hard on yourself
when rendering particularly mid tones which really benefit from being lifted up together
and if you want a cohesive drawing I and it’s not by any means canonical but my experience is
building it up in layers of of light to mid to dark tones pretty much the whole thing at once
and then getting darker and darker allows you to tweak and darken as you go along and really
accustom your eyes and your brain to the range of tones that are in there as they as they sort of
emerge and allows you to get quite soft shading and since I’m not particularly delicate of hand
it’s a technique that works well for me because I can build things up via layers that don’t
themselves necessarily have to be that perfect anyway no one listened to that I sort of gave up
trying about half an hour in and people were doing some approaches where they were very
methodical from one edge in others were much more frenetic and scribbly others were approaching it
somewhat more like what I would and everything in between and of the ones who really seemed to
lean into the task some found it sort of frustrating angry and had this level of perfectionism
which caused frustration and I had to sort of step in and kind of get them to relax a bit and
give them a few pointers others wouldn’t hear of any intervention and just patiently got on with
filling it in as they saw it and so on I got I’ve got a pile of these bits of paper with
varying degrees of finishedness probably about 100 of them and yeah there’s quite an array there
and some of them were just people going through the motions as quickly as possible so as not to
embrace the teacher but it’s really quite a dazzling array of approaches and I’ve done this
with adults as well and the same thing applies now I’m not an art teacher don’t think I ever will be
I don’t have any real desire to be so so any art teachers that happen to be listening to this
I doubt they’re learning anything new from what I’m saying and I don’t think I’ve observed anything
fundamental that isn’t pretty obvious but what I guess strikes me is that certainly I feel like
some of that diversity can dissipate and starts to dissipate I certainly don’t see a huge amount
of diversity outside of the the major art galleries and I do wonder whether some of that
exploratory style gets beaten out of people but even with the adults I see different approaches
and even when you take two artists who to my eye whose work seemed to come from a similar place
when you see them approaching exactly the same subject the radical differences in how they do
that it’s quite startling and then you look at their major body of work and it’s actually fairly
similar and I find all this really interesting I think is a point that ties back to the sort of
ingenuity that you see that within galleries and within the commercial art world I’ve too many
times I’ve been to commercial and contemporary art fairs and ended up chatting to the artists
who were going yeah I’ll do this stuff because it’s what makes the money what I’d rather be doing
is x and looking slightly full on about it and to a degree that’s what the market wants the market
wants what the market wants people tend to not want things that in terms of art that are going to be
on their walls long term that visitors are going to see that makes them stand out in ways that
they’re not sure about and so there’s a level to which people’s expectations uh play very much into
their art buying decisions and uh and as a result has that diversity of approaches and styles
disappeared as kids get older the ones that stay in engaged with art and creativity
have they lost that diversity that willingness to do things how they want to do it
it’s quite no means a representative cross section or a definitive proof but the adults who I work
with tend to be quite a lot older than me retirees and the diversity of styles I observe there are
just as radical even if the outputs don’t necessarily bear that out and let’s be clear
I’m not suggesting that all the wonderful people who are part of why wider art fraternity are
driving out homogeneous work there’s an immense amounts of creativity and stylistic individuality
on display lots of hard work and real real ability I don’t use the word talent I avoid
it at all costs that’s for another day it’s just that I think that the stuff that gets
gets seen by the wider world is the stuff that for the most part people feel is going to appeal
to the wider world and therefore some of that underlying diversity just gets hidden but it’s
still there and there’s a degree to which well that’s life that’s the world we live in we can’t
all be Jacob Rees-Mogg or one of these other anachronistic humans who can have a public persona
that is from a different time a different era Grayson Perry so on we’re not lucky enough to
be able to express ourselves in any way we want like Hockney or Damien Hirst or whoever you want
to mention because we have to sell arts to people who have an expectation of a certain type of art
we want to we can’t turn up in some bonkers fantasy mad something out of a different time
period cross-dressing garb like Grayson Perry because sometimes I have to turn up in an office
or go on conference calls and quite frankly prejudice is a side that type of thing is
likely to be a bit distracting so we hide those bits of ourselves and and that I find sad I don’t
find it sad that people want what they want I find it sad that so many artists out there have to spend
more of their time than they’d like producing stuff because it sells rather than producing stuff
because because it’s what they want because it’s really the true extension of their personality
and their experiences and it makes them happy and and given the thesis of this podcast
it’s making art for the masses because it makes money bad for your mental health
it could be I’m not convinced it is and I still think there’s worse ways to earn a living
worse ways for your mental health to earn a living and I do not begrudge criticize or belittle
people who do that one tiny little bit I I feel for you if you’re lucky enough to be producing
work that sells no matter what which also happens to be exactly what you want to be doing then I
tell you the luckiest person alive if you’re having to compromise your desires and your vision
simply because that vision is not you have not found a market for it I my heart goes out to you
and I think you’re the people on the front line you’re the people that are supporting the rest
of us bless you and keep fighting the good fight but don’t stop looking for the market
for what you really want to be doing try and find a way to do that because I think that for me
anyway the ability to work on wherever whatever suits me whatever makes me happy at that moment
to explore and to engage with new material subject matters approaches styles that makes
me happy it makes me relaxed and the inverse is true when I try and force myself to conform to
something or to stick to a particular thread for long periods that can actually have an entirely
detrimental effect on my mental health and I’m lucky enough that I can earn money elsewhere
to the degree that leaves me enough time and money to support myself and my family while also
spending plenty of time in the studio and experimenting and pissing around and I don’t
want that to change if it’s a case of having to do my day job for many many many more years
to support me being able to see what the hell ever I want then so be it I just don’t think
I have it in me to do otherwise doesn’t make me better doesn’t make me more of an artist doesn’t
make anyone else less of an artist it’s just a fact I know about myself and I think the other
thing to remember here is that sometimes you think that a lack of interest in the stuff that
you love the most equals a lack of market or or an actual lack of interest in that and that’s
just a reality but that’s never the case there’s a there’s a market and there’s an audience for
anything that someone is delivered with passion and love it just takes longer to find the audience
for some than it does for others and sometimes you have to create that audience sometimes you
have to find it sometimes that audience finds you sometimes you may feel like you’re alone in the
wilderness but suddenly the world comes around to meet you suddenly civilization is there around
you and uh because you’re stuck to your guns that now suddenly what you do is fashionable
and maybe you had something to do with that and maybe just doing your thing was all that ever
needed something happened recently to me I I went through a phase of doing really really big
paintings of people’s faces usually women usually very very close up often in old aspect ratios
often hyper realistic and quite what’s the word what is the words quite in your face not
necessarily challenging but certainly requiring a certain amount of attention and I like to work
big I find working small very very difficult I just don’t have delicate hands but uh big paintings
use lots of paint here’s lots of canvas if you have them stretched take up a lot of space and
it just it’s just stopped being feasible for me to work big so I haven’t stopped completely but
highly unusual now for me to stretch out a big canvas and do something like that which to be
clear I would love to do more of but either way I’ve got some of these around the place and
that have all been stretched and I just like them and uh and so I bring them out every now and again
and have them on show and think who’s got the wall space for this giant green staring lady
that’s probably about in a meter and a half square who’s got the space for this ultra close
cropped hyper real close up of a woman’s face most of which is not on the canvas some of my
favorite artworks but who’s got the space and who really wants to sit there in their dining room
or in their living room with this giant staring face that’s that was my interpretation and uh
that might be true for some people but the two pictures I’ve just described and if you go back
a couple of episodes you’ll hear the story of one of them selling it’s the episode about bees
can’t remember what number it is well the other one sold yesterday giant big green staring lady
one of the biggest pieces I ever did and uh I was just staggered when they said because they came
up to me at the pub and says you know that painting you’ve got in the in the picture house
you know the big green one with the staring lady would just sell us that one and I was like well
hell yeah but hold on let’s make sure are you sure are you sure that this is the one you want
let me show you a photo because are you absolutely sure that you want this one and I showed to them
yeah that’s the one and then they came around my house the next day and I was like right okay
he goes well how can I pay you I said no no let’s let’s take this and go and look at it in place
because only live up the road for me and make sure that you really want this and he was our
shrugs at yes sure white love let’s just go and do that almost shimmering me probably was and we
took it up there and their house is not big let’s be clear it’s not small either it’s just a cottage
it’s beautiful it’s one of the loveliest house I’ve been in but it’s not mansion which is what
I assumed you needed to house one of these big paintings and they have this living room of
gorgeous decor covered in really amazing artworks and the walls are green and it just happened
tonally that that shade of green worked very very well with the green in their living room and it
put it length up against the wall where it was going to hang and it’s like yeah it’s where it
wants to be that’s where it should be that’s where I want that painting so please sell it to me
but uh I mean it took up most of the war and uh and I just I just was liking okay great I mean
I’m really pleased about this and it looks amazing but I just didn’t think that customer existed
anyway just goes to show that your preconceptions about what people like and they what they don’t
what market exists out there for your work and what people are willing to put in their houses
is almost certainly wrong or at least skewed and so that was just a mentally positive experience
for me and now I’m thinking hey I’m going to do lots more giant staring ladies actually probably
not sure I’ve developed quite quite a big enough market for that yet but who knows I actually have
several more in my collection so what this really means is I get to dust off some older one stretch
them and stick them up hopefully there are more buyers for it from kids drawing spheres to uh
how to sell giant artworks with staring ladies there’s a market for it folks so if you’re uh
if you’re thinking that’s what you’d rather be doing then the delicate little watercolors you’re
doing right now then rock on art against mental illness